Idol’s Top 3 Pick Better Songs Than Judges, But Who Sang the Best?

American Idol is down to its Top 3 and for its 300th episode each of the guys had to sing two songs – a choice of their own and one chosen by one of the judges.  Hands down, the guys picked better songs than the judges.  But between the guys, the competition is going to be close.

Danny Gokey started out the night with a song chosen by Paula – “Dance Little Sister” by Terrence Trent D’Arby.  I’m not a big fan of the song to begin with, but I really didn’t like what Danny did to it.  The graveliness of his voice is really starting to grate on my nerves.  Personally, I thought it was a poor song choice and Danny did nothing to improve on it.

On the other hand, One Republic’s “Apologize” was the perfect song for Kris Allen’s voice and personality.  He did a beautiful rendition of the song.  And as Randy said, I think the song showed us what kind of future Kris has in the music business.  And that’s the kind of music, I would buy.

Likewise, Simon picked a beautiful song for Adam Lambert to belt out.  However, I have to say that I like U2’s version of “One” better than Adam’s.  First it started off a little too slow and then it was a bit too much in the middle.  But I give Adam props for adding his own spin to the song even if I didn’t favor it.

The guys returned for the second round with their own song choices.  Ryan made it sound like a really big deal, but isn’t that what they’ve been doing all along is choosing their own songs.  They just had a bigger selection to chose from this week.

Danny slowed things down with “You are so Beautiful” by Joe Cocker.  It’s a gorgeous song, but again I’m not finding anything appealing in Danny’s voice.  He didn’t do a bad job, but I find that all his songs fall into one of two sounds – upbeat (which includes the dancing) and ballad.  This sounded like all his other ballads.

But if Danny put me to sleep, Kris woke me up with an awesome acoustic version of Kayne West’s “Heartless.”  He might be quiet, humble and unassuming, but Kris will be remembered.  Its performances like this that make him stand out.  I can’t wait to hear this song again.

The night closed with Adam taking on “Crying.”  I’m a huge fan of Aerosmith so I was really looking forward to this performance.  It had real potential, but I had trouble hearing Adam.  The background singer kept singing over him and it really took away from the performance.  However, I enjoyed listening to a more “natural” Adam without the huge “performance” element.

Personally, I think it should be Adam and Kris in the final.  I think Kris won the night with “Heartless” and Adam’s “Crying” came in a close second. 

But at this point it’s not really about who had the best performance as much as who has the largest number of voting fans.  But I honestly think it will be a close call either way.

Related Posts

Idol Results: Danny Screeches to Safety

Idol’s Top 4 Add Duets to Rock Week

Adam in the Bottom 3 of Idol This Week

American Idol has Found its Own Rat Pack

Idol Down to Four Men, One Woman

Disco gets Remade by Idol’s Top 7

 Judges Use the Save, Idol Remains at 7

Adam Goes Wild with Cinema Hits on Idol

Suspense High on Idol’s Top 8 Results Show

Idol’s Top 8 Relive Music from their Birth Year

Simon Sends an Idol Home Without a Care

Idol Finds a Couple of Piano Men Among the Top 9

Motown Greats Rock American Idol Top 10 Results Show

Idol Guys Put a New Twist on Motown

Carrie Underwood Returns for Idol’s Shocking Top 11 Results

Randy Travis helps Idol’s Top 11 Find Their County Side

New Idol Rule Couldn’t Save Jorge, Jasmine from Elimination

Adam Shows the Race for the Idol Title isn’t ‘Black or White’


5 Responses to Idol’s Top 3 Pick Better Songs Than Judges, But Who Sang the Best?

  1. Amelia says:

    I think it will be a close call too.

    I was 80% sure we’d have to say goodbye to beloved Kris this week, until he turned up with that brilliant choice & arrangement, “Heartless”. Now Dial Idol has Kris as slightly ahead of Danny, but all 3 finalists are so close in their Dial Idol scores it is impossible to know who is likely to go home. Kris stands a solid chance of staying another week, though.

    I was (surprisingly) not a fan at all of what Adam did with either of his 2 songs. I like Adam a lot, but I hoped he would do a ‘Mad World’ type of thing with “One” because “One” has such beautiful, sensitive, vulnerable lyrics. The lyrics are ballad-like. Instead, Adam did go over the top in both songs in my opinion and I really lost any sort of emotional connection with Adam or his songs. I don’t only like Adam’s slow songs. I like his occasional fast song too (Black and White was brilliant). I’m not sure why I haven’t been ‘feeling’ his performances in the past 3 weeks. Is he interacting with his audience less? Is he smiling less? Are the song choices not memorable? Is the band too overpowering? Is the beat not funky and strong/catchy enough?

    I am not a fan of Danny’s husky voice or songs. I was not won over tonight. Both his songs were okay. I liked his slow start on his personal song choice. I think he excels in more upbeat songs like the judges; choice. However the judges’ choice song had a small range, a boring melody, and was very repetitive.

  2. sel22 says:

    Redlight’s blog is a true depiction of what happened on the show. More people should learn how to discern talents from the norm. I absolutely think Kris and Adam should be the last 2 in the finale . Personally I am tired of listening to Danny and I guess in the music industry, that shouldn’t be the case! Its like churning out CDs which will never be sold out. Pardon the harshness but well, that’s reality

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: